Season chicken generously with salt and season with black pepper to taste. Set aside for about 30 minutes.
Set aside your smoked turkey.
Blend 1 large onion, 3 garlic cloves, ginger and 2 scotch bonnets. Add at most about ⅓ cup of water when blending to help smoothen out the mixture. Set aside.
In a very large pot, add your chicken and smoked turkey and immediately pour over your onion, garlic, ginger and pepper mixture and add your anise seed.
Mix well so chicken and turkey are coated, cover chicken and turkey and let it steam for about 30 minutes until chicken is cooked. Your smoked turkey is already cooked.
In a separate pot, add 2 tomatoes, 1 onion, 2 garlic cloves and 1 scotch bonnet pepper. Pour over water and boil for about 30 minutes until tender.
When your tomato and onions are soft, let cool slightly before blending into a smooth puree.
Sieve this tomato mixture over your steamed chicken and turkey to remove pulp. Simmer on low while you prepare peanut mixture.
Add the peanut butter, tomato paste and about 1 cup of water to the blender and blend until smooth.
Pour your peanut mixture in a saucepan and mix on low-medium heat until it is smooth and thickened slightly. Add more water if it thickens too much. It may start to bubble so it is important to continuously stir to avoid splatter.
Pour this over your chicken and cook on low heat for at least 30-40 minutes until the oil has settled on top. While the soup is cooking down, you can add additional whole scotch bonnet to the soup for flavour and a little more heat.
The oil is from the chicken and the peanut butter. It may start to look foamy on top but this is normal, this is also from the peanut butter can just be mixed into the soup.
It is advisable to keep a kettle or pot of hot water going while you are cooking the soup so if you need to water down or thin out your soup, you are adding hot water and not room temperature water which slows down cooking.
Adjust the soup thickness with water if necessary as the soup is simmering and adjust for salt and pepper. You can add additional optional seasoning like paprika, dried herbs but I like to keep things simple.
Taste and adjust seasoning.